A new study indicates an overestimation of U.S. maternal mortality rates: How severe is it?

Published: Mar. 28, 2024
muratkoc/Getty Images

A recent study has boldly challenged the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) earlier report on U.S. maternal mortality rates. The new analysis of death certificates suggests a significant divergence from the CDC's disturbing conclusions, bringing the alarming mortality rate narrative under intensive scrutiny.

Previously, the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics reported a shocking 32.9 deaths per 100,000 births. The startling statistic, covered widely by media outlets and causing widespread concern, is now questioned by an alternative report proposing a conspicuously lower figure. Instead of the initially stated rate, the recent study suggests a considerably lower rate of 10.4 deaths per 100,000 births. However, not all aspects of maternal mortality have improved.

Despite the overall decrease, the racial disparity within U.S. maternal mortality remains distressing. Conforming to the initial study, even the new analysis affirms that black pregnant individuals are thrice as likely to face fatalities as white individuals, demonstrating a deep-seated issue that continues to plague the nation.

The main point of contention revolves around the data collection methods employed by the CDC. Researchers such as K.S. Joseph, the lead author of the recent publication, suspected errors in the classification of maternal deaths due to the 'pregnancy checkbox' on the national death certificate. The unchecked box ended up misattributing numerous unrelated deaths to maternal mortality.

By reevaluating death certificates from 1999-2002 and 2018-2021 and discarding those with only the pregnancy checkbox ticked, Joseph and his team arrived at the revised mortality rate. Despite the significant difference, the lowered rate aligns more closely with those reported among other affluent nations. But will this revelation be the start of a paradigm shift in understanding maternal mortality, or just dismiss the issue entirely? The medical and scientific community awaits the fallout of this groundbreaking study.


You must log in to post a comment.